59 total, 52 with a spot on the map.
| Name | When | Spots | Map |
|---|---|---|---|
| Algernon's Exotic Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Bag Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Boater Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Bolero Hat | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Bucket Hat | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Cat Skull Mask | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Cattleman Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Civil War Hardee Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Classic Raccoon Mountain Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Conductor's Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Crown Bucket Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Cutter Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Derby High Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Farmer's Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Fisherman's Hat | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | no set spot | |
| Flop Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Gaucho Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| High Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Homburg Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Jipijapa Panama Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Liberty Hat | Chapter 2 after “An American Pastoral Scene” missable | no set spot | |
| Military Cavalry Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Military Forage Cap | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Military Officer's Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Miner's Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Moonshine Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Morion Helmet | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Nevada Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Newsboy Cap | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Newsboy Flat Cap | Chapter 2 after “The Sheep and the Goats” missable | no set spot | |
| Pagan Skull Mask | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Panama Fedora Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Pig Mask | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Pinned Flop Hat | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Plantation Gambler's Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Rhodes Post Office Hats | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Roanoke Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Rodeo Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Scarecrow Derby Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Scarecrow Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Scarecrow Sombrero | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Slouch Bucket Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Straw Boater Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Straw Hat | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| The Mountaineer Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Tricorn Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Viking Helmet | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Western Homburg Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Wide Slouch Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Workman's Flat Cap | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Worn Flop Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Worn Stovepipe Top Hat | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Sun Hat | Chapter 5 missable | no set spot | |
| Military Mountie Hat | Chapter 6 | no set spot | |
| Chinese Skull Cap | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Gambler's Hat | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Ram Skull Mask | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Scarecrow Top Hat | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Worn Flat Cap | Epilogue 1 missable | no set spot |