35 total, 15 with a spot on the map.
| Name | When | Spots | Map |
|---|---|---|---|
| Potent Bitters | Chapter 1 | no set spot | |
| Potent Health Cure | Chapter 1 | no set spot | |
| Potent Miracle Tonic | Chapter 1 | no set spot | |
| Potent Snake Oil | Chapter 1 | no set spot | |
| Dynamite Arrow | Chapter 2 after “A Short Walk in a Pretty Town” | 1 | Map |
| Express Explosive | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Fire Arrow | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Fire Bottle | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Herbivore Bait | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Homing Tomahawk | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Horse Ointment | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Horse Reviver | Chapter 2 after “American Distillation” | 1 | Map |
| Improved Arrow | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Improved Throwing Knife | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Improved Tomahawk | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Poison Arrow | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Poison Throwing Knife | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Potent Herbivore Bait | Chapter 2 after “Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego” | no set spot | |
| Potent Horse Medicine | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Potent Horse Stimulant | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Potent Predator Bait | Chapter 2 after “Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego” | no set spot | |
| Predator Bait | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Shotgun Shells (Incendiary Buckshot) | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Small Game Arrow | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Special Bitters | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Special Health Cure | Chapter 2 after “American Distillation” | 1 | Map |
| Special Horse Medicine | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Special Horse Stimulant | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Special Miracle Tonic | Chapter 2 after “A Short Walk in a Pretty Town” | 1 | Map |
| Special Snake Oil | Chapter 2 after “American Distillation” | 1 | Map |
| Split Point Cartridge | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Volatile Dynamite | Chapter 2 after “American Distillation” | 1 | Map |
| Volatile Fire Bottle | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Explosive Slug | Chapter 3 | 1 | Map |
| Horse Meal | Chapter 3 | no set spot |