15 total, 14 with a spot on the map.
| Name | When | Spots | Map |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bluegill | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Bullhead Catfish | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Chain Pickerel | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Lake Sturgeon | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Longnose Gar | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Muskie | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Northern Pike | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Perch | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Smallmouth Bass | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Sockeye Salmon | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Steelhead Trout | Chapter 2 after “A Fisher of Men” | 1 | Map |
| Channel Catfish | Epilogue 1 | no set spot | |
| Largemouth Bass | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Redfin Pickerel | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Rock Bass | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |