172 total, 160 with a spot on the map.
| Name | When | Spots | Map |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mining Company Letter to Cornwall | Chapter 1 missable | 1 | Map |
| Oil Company Letter to Cornwall | Chapter 1 missable | 1 | Map |
| A Day's Walk Poem | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| America | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Bennett Brothers Newspaper Scrap | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Blackwater Ledger Scrap | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Bounty Poster - Mr Black & Mr White | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Bride Photograph | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Charity Handbill | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Charles Châtenay's Sketch | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Chelonian Handbill | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Civil War Report | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Dear Annabella Poem | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Dutch's Speech Notes | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Dutch's Wanted Poster | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| English Spelling Practice | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Eugenics Handbill | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Experiment Notes 1 | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Experiment Notes 2 | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Experiment Notes 3 | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Experiment Notes 4 | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Faded Letter | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Farm, Field and Falconry | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Francis's Business Card | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Get Rich Quick | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Gideon Bennett Bounty Poster | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Grave Newspaper Clipping | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Gray Family History Letter | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Hopes For The Future | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Inventor's Plan | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Invitation from Deborah MacGuiness | Chapter 2 | 11 | Map |
| Invitation from Francis Sinclair | Chapter 2 | 11 | Map |
| Invitation from Jeremy Gill | Chapter 2 | 11 | Map |
| Invitation from Ms. Hobbs | Chapter 2 | 11 | Map |
| Jack's Drawing | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Jeremy's Business Card | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Legendary Animal Map | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Legendary Fish Map | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Lemoyne Raiders Letter | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter from Cornwall Kerosene & Tar | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter from Mary | Chapter 2 | 6 | Map |
| Letter from Miss Marjorie | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter from Ms. Hobbs | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter from Scruffers & Co. Publishers (Female Rhodes) | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter from Scruffers & Co. Publishers (Male Rhodes) | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter from Scruffers & Co. Publishers (Male Saint Denis) | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter from St. Luke's Academy | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter from Theodore Levin | Chapter 2 | 11 | Map |
| Letter to Annette from Claude | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Anthony from Dad | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Bubba from Jillian | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Curtis from M | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Edmund from Mother | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Garfield from Martha | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Glen and Eddie from Momma | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Henrietta Douglas | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Herbert from Herberta | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Jim from Mildred | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Judge Finley | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Margaret from Arnold | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Martha from Garfield | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Martin from Father | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Letter to Mavis from Larry | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Mayor Timmins from Belinda | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Miriam Wegner | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Nate from Momma | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Nigel from Tom | Chapter 2 missable | 7 | Map |
| Letter to Pa | Chapter 2 | 15 | Map |
| Letter to the Doctor from Donal | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to the Editor | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to the Saint Denis Times Tribune | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Uncle Lewis from Elijah | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to William Errington | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Liability Agreement | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| List of Debtors | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Lost Letter to Bonnie | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Meeting Notes | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Mended Map | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Micah Newspaper Scrap | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Missing Person Poster | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Murfree Brood Prisoner's Note | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Murfree Brood Ransom Note | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Mysterious Sermon | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Newspaper Scrap | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 1 | Chapter 2 after “Eastward Bound” | 6 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 2 | Chapter 2 after “Pouring Forth Oil IV” | 6 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 3 | Chapter 2 after “The Sheep and the Goats” | 6 | Map |
| Nite Folk Victim's Note | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Nite Folk Wagerer's Note | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Note from Jim | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Note from Robert Elliot Patchen | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Note from the Sculptor | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Note to Ma | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Note to Mother | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Otis Miller and the Arabian Prince | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Otis Miller and the Black-Hearted Lady | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Otis Miller and the Boy from New York | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Panoramic Map | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Phineas's Business Card | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Pieced Together Map | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Property Deed | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Rambles Through Woods and Plains | Chapter 2 missable | 6 | Map |
| River Lure Handbill | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Saint Denis Trolley Riders Digest | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Slim Grant Photograph | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Special Lake Lure Handbill | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Special River Lure Handbill | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Special Swamp Lure Handbill | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Swamp Lure Handbill | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| The Case of the Shrew in the Fog | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Undelivered Mail x5 | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Watson's Scrapbook Page | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Wedding Certificate | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Wild Man's Journal | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Wild West Heroes, No. 132 | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Wolves Photograph | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Young Mary & Arthur Photograph | Chapter 2 after “We Loved Once and True I” | no set spot | |
| Zoological Compendium | Chapter 2 missable | 6 | Map |
| Lake Lure Handbill | Chapter 3 | 1 | Map |
| Mine Share | Chapter 3 missable | 1 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 4 | Chapter 3 after “Magicians for Sport” | 6 | Map |
| Son's Drawing | Chapter 3 missable | 1 | Map |
| Algernon's Business Card | Chapter 4 missable | no set spot | |
| Electric Chair Blueprint | Chapter 4 missable | 1 | Map |
| Inventor's Note | Chapter 4 missable | 1 | Map |
| Invitation from Mayor Lemieux | Chapter 4 | 11 | Map |
| Letter from Charles Châtenay | Chapter 4 | 11 | Map |
| Letter from the Mayor's Office | Chapter 4 | 11 | Map |
| Letter to Angelo Bronte | Chapter 4 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Bronte from the Mayor | Chapter 4 missable | 1 | Map |
| List of Accounts | Chapter 4 missable | 1 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 5 | Chapter 4 after “The Joys of Civilization” | 6 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 6 | Chapter 4 after “Urban Pleasures” | 6 | Map |
| Rare Orchids Order | Chapter 4 missable | 11 | Map |
| Second Invitation from Mayor Lemieux | Chapter 4 | 11 | Map |
| Second Letter from Mary | Chapter 4 | 6 | Map |
| Telegram to Police Chief Lambert | Chapter 4 missable | 1 | Map |
| Theatre Ticket | Chapter 4 missable | no set spot | |
| Newspaper, Issue 7 | Chapter 5 after “Dear Uncle Tacitus” | 6 | Map |
| A Letter from Penelope | Chapter 6 | 6 | Map |
| Goodbye Letter from Mary | Chapter 6 | no set spot | |
| Letter from 'Caroline' | Chapter 6 missable | no set spot | |
| Letter from Charlotte | Chapter 6 missable | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Tom from Colm | Chapter 6 missable | 1 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 10 | Chapter 6 after “The King's Son” | 6 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 8 | Chapter 6 after “Visiting Hours” | 6 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 9 | Chapter 6 after “The Bridge to Nowhere” | 6 | Map |
| Cholera Handbill | Epilogue 1 | 2 | Map |
| Erotic Photograph 1 | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Erotic Photograph 2 | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Erotic Photograph 3 | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Erotic Photograph 4 | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Erotic Photograph 5 | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Alfred from Annabel | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Alfred from Matilda | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Jacob from Father | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Mandy | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Momma | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Mother from Miles | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Letter to Zhou Yi from Zhou Wei | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 11 | Epilogue 1 after “The Wheel” | 6 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 12 | Epilogue 1 after “The Landowning Classes” | 6 | Map |
| Norwegian Journal Page | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Norwegian Newspaper Scrap | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Norwegian Photo | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| The Lady of the Manor | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| True Tales of Frank Heck, No. 102 | Epilogue 1 | 1 | Map |
| Unfinished Letter | Epilogue 1 | 2 | Map |
| Letter to Brother Rodolfo | Epilogue 2 | 1 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 13 | Epilogue 2 after “Uncle's Bad Day” | 6 | Map |
| Newspaper, Issue 14 | Epilogue 2 after “American Venom” | 6 | Map |
| Telegram from Sadie | Epilogue 2 | no set spot |