90 total, 29 with a spot on the map.
| Name | When | Spots | Map |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amass a $250 bounty in one state. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Beat the Blackjack dealer in two locations (Rhodes and Van Horn). | Chapter 2 | 2 | Map |
| Beat the Five Finger Fillet player in every location (Strawberry, Valentine, Van Horn). | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Break every wild horse breed. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Bust one poker location out in each location (Flatneck Station, Saint Denis, Valentine). | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Call an animal and get a clean kill 5 times. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Catch 3 Bluegill. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Catch 3 small fishes without using a fishing rod. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Catch a fish in the Bayou from a riverboat and while standing on train tracks. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Catch a fish that weighs at least 19 lbs (8.9 kg). | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Catch an opossum playing possum. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Catch one of each type of fish throughout the world. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Collect 3 perfect quality rabbit pelts. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Craft 7 items using sage as an ingredient. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Craft 9 items using Indian Tobacco as an ingredient. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Craft a dynamite, fire, improved, poison, and small game arrow. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Craft a homing tomahawk, improved tomahawk, volatile dynamite, and volatile fire bottle. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Craft and use 5 special miracle tonics. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Disarm 3 enemies without reloading or switching your weapon. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure Map. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find a Treasure. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Find and kill the legendary panther "Giaguaro". | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Get 7 headshots in a row. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Hand 5 animals into camp or trapper. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Hold up 5 townsfolk. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| In Blackjack, double down and win the hand 5 times. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Jump over 3 obstacles in 15 seconds. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Kill 10 enemies with a shotgun using crafted ammo. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 15 enemies using a long-barreled sidearm. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 2 different species of animal in the same Dead Eye use. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 3 birds of prey using only a tomahawk. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 3 enemies in 10 seconds using only throwing knives. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 3 enemies with a knife. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 3 flying birds with 3 consecutive long scoped rifle shots. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 3 flying birds. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 4 consecutive enemies by throwing and retrieving the same tomahawk. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 4 enemies at the same time with a single stick of dynamite. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 5 animals with a varmint rifle. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 5 cougars with your bow, then skin them. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 5 flying birds while on a moving train. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 5 mounted enemies, using 1 throwing knife per kill. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 5 rabbits from horseback. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 6 animals without switching or reloading your weapon. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Kill 7 enemies from horseback without dismounting. | Chapter 2 | 2 | Map |
| Kill 8 small game animals with consecutive shots, using small game arrows. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Kill 9 predators from horseback. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill 9 unaware enemies from behind, using the bow. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Kill a grizzly bear without taking damage, using only throwing knives. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill a scavenging animal while it is feeding a corpse 5 times. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill someone at 80 feet away with a tomahawk. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Kill someone at at least 660 feet away with a long scoped rifle. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Pick 15 different species of herb. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Pick 5 mushrooms and feed them to your horse. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Pick 6 Yarrow. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Pick and eat 4 species of berry. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Ride from Strawberry to Saint Denis in less than 9 minutes without touching any water. | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Ride from Valentine to Rhodes in less than 5 minutes. | Chapter 2 | 2 | Map |
| Ride from Van Horn to Blackwater in less than 17 minutes without touching any water. | Chapter 2 | 2 | Map |
| Rob any 2 coaches or return any 2 stolen coaches to the Fence. | Chapter 2 | 2 | Map |
| Rob any 3 coaches or return any 3 stolen coaches to the Fence in a day. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Rob the cash register in any 4 shops in one day. | Chapter 2 | 3 | Map |
| Shoot 3 people's hats off in the same Dead Eye use. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Skin 3 black or grizzly bears. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Skin 3 deer. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Track 10 different animal species using your binoculars. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Trample 5 animals while on horseback. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Use bait to lure and kill both a herbivore and predator. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Use oleander to craft 6 poison weapons. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| While mounted, drag a victim for 3300 feet using your lasso. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Win 3 games of dominoes in a row. | Chapter 2 | 2 | Map |
| Win 3 games of Five Finger Fillet. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Win 3 hands of Blackjack with 3 hits or more. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Win 3 hands of Poker in a row. | Chapter 2 | no set spot | |
| Win 3 rounds of dominoes without drawing any tiles against 2 or fewer opponents. | Chapter 2 | 2 | Map |
| Win 5 hands of Poker. | Chapter 2 | 1 | Map |
| Complete 5 train robberies without dying or being caught. | Chapter 3 | 1 | Map |
| Hogtie someone and leave them on the railroad 3 times. | Chapter 3 | no set spot | |
| Rob $50 worth of cash and valuables from townsfolk and travelers. | Chapter 3 | no set spot | |
| Steal 5 horses and sell them to the Horse Fence at Clemens Cove. | Chapter 3 | 1 | Map |
| Steal 7 wagons and sell them to the Fence at Emerald Ranch. | Chapter 3 | 1 | Map |
| Pick one of each species of herb. | Epilogue 1 | no set spot | |
| Season and cook all 11 types of meat. | Epilogue 1 | no set spot |