22 total, 9 with a spot on the map.
| Name | When | Spots | Map |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abigail — $5 | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Bill — Hair Pomade | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Charles — Moonshine (Fire Arrows) | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Charles — Oleander Sage (Poison Arrows) | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Dutch – Pipe | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Hosea – The Case of the Shrew in the Fog | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Jack – Penny Dreadful Comic Book | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Jack — Abigail's Thimble | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Javier — Oleander Sage | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Lenny – Silver Pocket Watch | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Mary-Beth – Fountain Pen | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Pearson – Naval Compass | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Pearson — Unskinned Rabbit | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Sean — Kentucky Bourbon | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Susan — Oregano ×2 | Chapter 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Tilly – Gold Pendant Necklace | Chapter 2 missable | 1 | Map |
| Hosea — American Ginseng ×2 | Chapter 3 missable | no set spot | |
| Kieran — Burdock Root ×2 | Chapter 3 missable | no set spot | |
| Molly – Pocket Mirror | Chapter 3 missable | 1 | Map |
| Sadie – Harmonica | Chapter 3 missable | 1 | Map |
| Charles — Eagle Feathers | Epilogue 2 missable | no set spot | |
| Uncle — Home Remedy Ingredients | Epilogue 2 missable | no set spot |